Did the property sector lose out in Budget 2014?

By Khairie Hisyam

budget-2014-inside-story-banner

Goods and services tax (GST) and its tax-break balms aside, property and housing took centre stage in Budget 2014. With a series of cooling measures alongside more affordable housing goodies, KiniBiz analyses the lay of the land for the property sector post-Budget 2014.

______________________________________________________________________

In terms of the property sector, the highlights of Budget 2014 were the ban on the much-debated developer interest-bearing scheme (DIBS) as well as the prohibition on financial institutions from financing DIBS-related projects, as well as the hike in real property gains tax (RPGT) rates.

In addition, the minimum property purchase price for foreigners was doubled from RM500,000 to RM1 million, while developers are now required to disclose detailed sales prices including all “freebies” that often come with property purchases today.

The emerging picture represents a continuation of anti-speculative measures already unveiled in recent years.

Indirectly, the unveiling of such measures last week signals strong intention by the government to continue addressing housing affordability concerns, who are increasingly priced out of the housing market in urban migration hotspots.

property-display-mockup-buildings-housesCollectively, the three main measures — DIBS ban, RPGT hike and minimum price increase — seem aimed at restraining speculative activity and demand, which if successful would arrest the speculation-driven escalation of property prices, slowing down price growth to be more sustainable in light of recent housing affordability concerns.

On the other hand, the affordable housing initiatives — allocations for the construction of affordable houses, introduction of the MyHome scheme, as well as the proposed establishment of the National Housing Council — announced in the Budget indicate that home ownership remains a priority for the government.

Will this Budget’s property cooling measures achieve its underlying objectives of curbing speculation without affecting genuine demand?

The DIBS party is officially over

Policies to curb speculation 011113Among the announced measures, the ban on DIBS as well as forbidding any financing for DIBS-related projects will perhaps have the most immediate effect on the property industry, as this directly impacts developers and their buyers.

“Of the three property measures, the ban on DIBS is likely to have the biggest impact on the property sector,” said CIMB Research Terence Wong in a report after the Budget 2014 speech. “Nearly all developers offer DIBS.”

Ng Seing Liong

Ng Seing Liong

Talk had surfaced that Bank Negara is considering such a ban as early as June this year, with a banking source informing KiniBiz that the central bank had actually begun looking at the scheme circa 2009 — notably also the year Singapore imposed a ban on the scheme.

“We already knew that DIBS will be taken out of the picture,” said Real Estate and Housing Developers (REHDA) immediate past president Ng Seing Liong to KiniBiz.

In his speech last week, prime minister Najib Abdul Razak said the ban is to prevent developers from incorporating interest rates during the construction period into the mortgage itself, which has a longstanding contention by those opposing the scheme.

“Therefore, financial institutions are prohibited from providing final funding for projects involved in the DIBS scheme,” said Najib.

How drastic will the impact be?

The ban, though cheered by many property observers, is not entirely unexpected, having been a hot topic in the market for quite a while now. Consequently, many developers have hedged their bets on a potential ban by avoiding the scheme altogether in newer projects.

“You can see this through the current new projects launched which majority were without DIBS,” said Lim Hock San, managing director of LBS Bina Group, which has a 16% exposure to DIBS in its 18 on-going projects.

A Sime Darby Property spokesperson informed KiniBiz that the impact of the ban would be negligible as only about 1% of the developer’s available units at present are offered with DIBS.

“We expect this ban to impact developers of high-end condominiums who offer DIBS in their package to attract property investors,” said Selangor State Development Corporation (PKNS) general manager Othman Omar to KiniBiz.

One positive of the DIBS restriction on top of making the pricing of properties more transparent in terms of benefits and incentives offered to buyers such as exemption of legal fees, stamp duty, sales agreements, cash rebates and free gifts is that the pricing becomes clearer.

In comparison, the selling price often does not reflect the cost of DIBS and such “freebies”, though they are often built into the selling price.

“If buyers buy at RM800,000 and get kickbacks of RM100,000 worth in freebies, subsequent buyers do not see that — they only see the RM800,000 figure,” said Universiti Teknologi Mara (UiTM) head of the Centre for Real Estate Research (CORE) Professor Dr Ting Kien Hwa to KiniBiz. “So now the pricing would not be so hazy.”

Overall, the emerging potential aftermath from the DIBS ban is that while there may be a knee-jerk reaction to the ban in the property market, the actual impact may not be too severe.

“Developers with properties that are well located and reasonably priced will be able to thrive, with or without DIBS,” said Wong of CIMB, citing Mah Sing’s Southville township development that saw overwhelming response despite not offering DIBS.

LBS Bina chief Lim shares the sentiment, saying that developers’ best strategy remains offering projects with strategic location with the right offering at the right price.

However, marketing creativity knows no bounds and the property market is no exception — the introduction of DIBS in the first place is a testament to developers’ ingenuity.

With DIBS out of the picture, the logical next step for developers is figuring out how to achieve the same results that the use of DIBS had helped them gain now that the scheme is no longer an option.

The underlying possibility is that down the road the property sector may see another innovative scheme or two aimed at driving sales.

“The invisible hand of the market always moves faster than the heavy hand of the government,” said Khoo of ENK Ventures to KiniBiz.

RPGT rates stricter than ever

comparison of real property gains tax rates-pngBudget 2014 also unveiled revised RPGT rates for property disposals, with property disposals within three years of purchase now subject to a 30% tax compared to the 15% RPGT rate for disposals within two years of purchase previously.

“(The rates revision aims) to increase the ability of the rakyat to buy a house and ensure stable house prices, as well as to control excessive speculative activities,” said Najib in his Budget 2014 speech.

The new rates, appear to be a response to calls for the RPGT to return to  the rates that were previously in effect prior to the temporary blanket RPGT exemption between April 1, 2007 and Dec 31, 2009, by virtue of the RPGT (Exemption) (No.2) Order 2007.

But one important difference is that the 30% rate now applies to disposals within the first three years of ownership instead of two years previously before the exemption.

“(30% for disposals within) two years would not have done anything because after two years the construction period would be up already,” said Malaysian Institute of Estate Agents president Siva Shanker to KiniBiz after the Budget speech.

Additionally, foreigners now are subject to a flat 30% RPGT rate for disposals within the first five years of purchase, with 5% tax rate applicable for disposals in subsequent years.

“The RPGT rate after five years ought to be zero (for foreigners),” said Mani Usilappan, principal of Mani Usilappan chartered surveyors.

The new rates structure is in-line with the government’s aim to slow down the steep rises in property prices by promoting long-term ownership and discourage investors from flipping — selling properties quickly after vacant possession for fast returns, resulting in rapid price appreciation in a short span of time.

“Genuine investors and property buyers will be not affected at all as after five years RPGT goes down to 0%,” said REI Group of Companies CEO and co-founder Dr Daniele Gambero to KiniBiz.

Prices not likely to drop

Is rising debt a concern?However, the stricter RPGT rates is not expected to cause house prices to fall, as RPGT only discourages flipping among property investors not willing to fork out more in terms of tax.

There has even been the argument that higher RPGT rates would actually cause price appreciation to accelerate, pointing to historical data for Malaysia and Singapore that shows prices rising even after cooling measures meant to dampen price appreciation were introduced.

One scenario that might arise from the higher RPGT rates is that investors may push for higher sale prices in order to absorb the 30% tax rate, said property investor and author Faizul Ridzuan.

At worst case scenario, property flippers may continue flipping despite the higher tax rate because they still make money in the end — it is just a question of how much.

“Considering the deep pockets of property speculators, the effectiveness of these proposals remains to be seen but, when passed, will make speculation unworthwhile,” said Chang Kim Loong, honorary secretary-general of the National House Buyers Association (HBA) to KiniBiz.

Therefore RPGT rates may see more tweaking down the road depending on how effective it is perceived to be, especially since the current rates are applicable to both the primary and secondary market.

“The big speculation is in the primary market, not so much in the secondary market,” said MIEA’s Siva to KiniBiz. “(With the new RPGT rates) you are hurting the secondary market as well.”

Malaysian Institute of Estate Agents (MIEA) president Siva Shanker

Siva Shanker

Siva added that one way to be more effective in addressing speculation is to redefine the period for which RPGT is applicable, specifically changing the context from “from purchase” to “from vacant posession”.

“If (it is) something like two years from vacant possession, then (investors) are going to be (more) careful before they rush to the next property purchase,” said Siva to KiniBiz.

It is worth noting that when RPGT was reinstated in the 2010 Budget, the Federation of Chinese Associations of Malaysia (Hua Zhong) appealed for leniency.

In Budget 2010, RPGT rates were set at 5% across the board to end the RPGT exemption between April 1, 2007 and Dec 31, 2009.

Following Hua Zhong’s appeal, prime minister Najib Abdul Razak announced a reversal by declaring that the tax would only be imposed for property disposals within five years of ownership, meaning the government forwent some RM200 million in revenue.

“This was also decided upon as the Government wants to see a stronger growth in the property sector next year. We are willing to forgo a substantial amount of revenue so that the sector can expand and grow,” said Najib in December 2009.

Raising the entry bar for foreign property buyers

house-for-sale-thumbnailAlso among the cooling measures in Budget 2014 is the increase of the minimum property purchase price for foreigners from RM500,000 to RM1 million, which the prime minister said is aimed at stabilising prices and controlling excessive speculation.

“Foreigners must be prevented from ‘snapping up’ property meant for the lower and middle income and thus artificially inflating property prices and creating a domino effect which can result in higher property prices across the industry,” said HBA’s Chang in responding to the Budget 2014.

Sean Di Gregorio, chief executive officer of online property portal iProperty.com commented on business radio BFM that this particular move appears to be more targeted towards addressing loud concerns over foreign buyers who are perceived to be driving up prices, citing the low actual numbers of foreigners buying in the property market.

His remarks echo that of REHDA immediate past president Ng, who feels that the blanket measure unnecessarily assumes the situation in urban migration hotspots as applicable to the rest of the country.

“What happens to places like Kuantan and Melaka where the prices of properties have not reached RM1 million?” said Ng to KiniBiz. “In essence you are discouraging foreign investment into the country.”

In any case, the raised minimum purchase price is unlikely to affect foreigners buying properties in Malaysia, said Wong of CIMB Research, given that most luxury properties in Malaysia are priced above the RM1 million mark.

Iskandar Malaysia logo“Even in Iskandar Malaysia, Singapore buyers have a preference for larger and more expensive units, most of which are priced above RM1 million,” said Wong.

Therefore one possible outcome of the raised minimum price is that developers may start offering bigger built-ups for residential properties aimed at foreigners so as to sidestep the RM1 million limitation.

One notable exception is Medini Iskandar, a 2,230 area where the minimum property purchase price for foreigners does not apply. Additionally, certain foreign buyers who qualify are also exempt from RPGT up to year 2020 under the Medini Incentive Support Package by the Iskandar Regional Development Authority (IRDA).

In his Budget 2014 speech, prime minister Najib Abdul Razak did not mention whether the exemption for Medini Iskandar would be revoked, nor has the Ministry of Finance clarified the matter.

Thus the presumption at the moment is status quo remains.

“I don’t think (the raised minimum price limit) will be applicable to Medini,” said property lawyer Pretam Singh Darshan Singh when contacted by KiniBiz.

Property market impact of Budget 2014

In a post-Budget 2014 report, CIMB Research head Wong said that the physical property market is likely to see a lull for a few months, similar to what followed previous cooling measures such as the RPGT hike and the financing margin cap for third house purchases onwards.

“We think that when (buyers) realise that prices are not going south and are holding firm or even edging up, buying will return to normalcy,” added Wong in the report.

Malaysia Prime Minister Najib Abdul Razak

Najib Abdul Razak

In favour of the property market is that residential property transactions will be exempt from GST when the new tax comes into force, with  prime minister Najib Abdul Razak saying that sale, purchase and rental of residential properties as well as selected financial services are exempted from GST.

However this may lead to some confusion, as some developers has tried to circumvent the third property financing margin restriction by selling commercial properties intended for residential use.

“The biggest question mark now is whether these commercial properties will be reclassified as residential for GST purposes,” said TY Teoh International National Tax Director & ConsulNet Tax Services Sdn Bhd managing director Richard Oon to KiniBiz.

“We really have to look at the eventual GST guidelines for clarification on this question,” added Oon.

As for the financial sector, the RPGT hike in addition to the DIBS ban and the raised minimum property purchase price for foreigners would collectively impact the residential mortgage segment negatively, said CIMB Research analyst Winson Ng, as the segment is the key driver for overall loan growth for banks.

“This, to a certain extent, supports our expectations of a slowdown in the growth of residential mortgages from 12.9% yoy in Aug 2013 to a more sustainable pace of 11-12% in 2013-14,” said Ng in a report after the Budget 2014 speech.

One council to rule them all

Financial allocations towards affordable housing aside, Budget 2014 also unveiled a new National Housing Council, a move lauded across the property industry.

The council’s objectives are “to develop strategies and action plans in a holistic manner; coordinate legal aspects and property price mechanism; and ensure provision of homes in a more efficient and expeditious manner”, said prime minister Najib Abdul Razak.

“New pr1ma house thumbThe council members will comprise Federal Agencies, State Governments, the National Housing Department, PR1MA, SPNB and the private sector,” added Najib.

Such a council is long overdue, given that the country has not seen any entity undertaking a regulating role to ensure cohesion among various government housing initiatives at both the federal and state government levels.

“Even the housing ministry do not play the function well in terms of project housing needs, demand, policies etc,” said UiTM professor Ting to KiniBiz.

While how its actual implementation remains to be seen, it represents a positive step forward in addressing the housing needs of the people in tandem with cooling measures aimed at putting a lid on speculative activities.

Once established, one of the council’s main challenges would be to consolidate the myriad housing initiatives across the country in order to be more effective in providing affordable housing to the people.

“I think we need (this) sort of initiative on housing to formalise a national housing policy — we don’t have (such a national policy) yet,” said UiTM’s Ting. “It’s not clear cut, it’s very hazy.”

And there is a need for long-term planning and policies instead of those being made on an ad-hoc basis, according to Yeow Tit Sang, president of the International Real Estate Federation (FIABCI)’s Malaysian chapter.

Another aspect would be to provide a counterweight to the private sector’s voice in influencing the government’s decision-making with regards to housing matters.

“Certainly (the National Housing Council) is much needed as the private developers have strong lobbying power vis buyers,” said DTZ Nawawi Tie Leung Property Consultants executive director Brian Koh to KiniBiz.

“Hopefully this body can balance public needs with corporate profit objectives,” added Koh.

Yesterday: Tax breaks to soothe the sting of GST