GST and you

By Chan Quan Min

budget-2014-inside-story-banner-fixedThe long anticipated Goods and Services Tax was finally announced in last Friday’s Budget 2014 speech for implementation in 2015. KiniBiz asks tax professionals for their take on GST and found the responses to be in praise of the Prime Minister.

 ______________________________________________________________________

There were no big surprises in Budget 2014 and this was certainly for the better as Prime Minister Najib Abdul Razak took the right steps towards fiscal prudence, tax professionals say.

Without a doubt, Goods and Services Tax (GST) took centre stage in this budget, KPMG tax partner Pauline Tam said. “While on the topic of the budget, we cannot escape from talking about GST, which was a timely decision by Najib.”

Najib-budget-2014-pix-02In his Budget 2014 speech last Friday, Prime Minister Najib, who also holds the post of Finance Minister, pledged to implement the much-anticipated Goods and Services Tax (GST) by April 2015. At the same time, sales tax and service tax would be abolished.

Najib’s decision was a long time coming. GST was mentioned in the 2005 budget speech. In 2009, a Goods and Services Tax Bill made it as far as Parliament but was stalled after the government backed down from implementing GST, citing the need for a redraft.

Back in 2009, opposition to GST was particularly strong, coming from a galvanised opposition bloc fresh from major wins in the 2008 general election. Understandably, introducing a ‘new tax’ was always going to be an unpopular move.

For the next few years, introduction of a GST would continue to be politically inconvenient.

That is, until this year. After Barisan Nasional retained control of the federal government in the 2013 general election in May, it appeared the time was right for the government to finally announce a GST framework.

The country was in urgent need of tax reform to trim the fiscal deficit and broaden the tax base after the government had targeted a reduction in the fiscal deficit to 3% of gross domestic product (GDP) by 2015.

Opposing views on GST

While tax professionals and economists hail Najib’s announcement of GST as a sound move towards balancing the budget, opposition politicians did not take kindly to the introduction of a value-added consumption tax.

Opposition alliance Pakatan Rakyat made it very clear just prior to last week’s budget announcement that they were against GST.

Pakatan Rakyat’s alternative budget proposed reigning in spending instead of growing tax revenue, as is the intended purpose of implementing GST. The opposition bloc said even without new sources of tax revenue a balanced budget by 2018 was possible if frivolous spending was curtailed.

In an immediate reaction to the budget, opposition leader Anwar Ibrahim claimed GST would only “punish the people” and widen the rift between the rich and the poor. This is because the consumption tax is regressive in nature.

Chartered Tax Institute of Malaysia (CTIM) president SM Thanneermalai

SM Thanneermalai

Commenting on Budget 2014 immediately after Najib’s speech, Chartered Tax Institute of Malaysia president SM Thanneermalai said the government has done what was necessary to avert a feared credit rating downgrade.

“If anything, in the medium to long run we may be getting better ratings,” he added.

Malaysia was put on watch for a possible credit downgrade after Fitch Ratings revised downwards the country’s economic outlook in August.

Reports suggested the country could see a credit downgrade if the fiscal deficit situation did not improve. Malaysia has been running a fiscal deficit for about 15 years now.

Speaking to KiniBiz, Thanneermalai said he was pleased with Najib’s light touch with regard to next year’s government spending:

“Najib has done what he can within the budget. If you think about this budget, he has not given incentives or tax breaks all over the place. He’s been quite frugal and responsible in that sense.

Indeed, budget estimates for 2014 list a 1.3% fall in developmental expenditure for next year as well as much slower growth, compared to previous years, in operational expenditure of just 0.7%

Within operational expenditure, the subsidy bill for 2014 has been cut 15.6%, the first time in five years to see a reduction in the allocation for subsidies.

“His position will be much better in terms of revenue collection. There will be a steady stream of tax coming in based on consumption instead of replying on the profits of companies.”

On tax reform, Thanneermalai said Najib has made sufficient structural changes to address the needs of the economy. GST would reduce the current reliance on corporate tax as a source of government revenue.

Compared to consumption taxes, corporate tax collections can fluctuate on the country’s economic performance.

GST to kick in at a higher than expected rate

In 2009 when the Goods and Services Tax Bill was first presented to parliament, the quoted introductory GST rate was 4%, which was found to be the revenue-neutral rate in the replacement of sales tax and service Tax.

tax-receiptsBut last Friday, Najib’s proposed GST model for introduction in April 2015 quoted a tax rate of 6%, on the high side of the possible band of 4% to 7% hinted at in presentations by the Ministry of Finance.

“We are biting the bullet at 6%. It’s good in that we don’t have to tinker with it,” Thanneermalai said of the higher tax rate.

The slightly higher introductory GST rate, Thanneermalai explained, would allow the government to go without increases for several years after introduction.

Conversely, if the government had implemented GST at a low rate of 4%, an increase in the rate would become inevitable before the end of a few years. This is because a rate of 4% would not result in any increase tax revenue for the government.

At a rate of 6%, the government is expected to collect RM23.1 billion and RM32 billion in GST for 2015 (nine month period) and 2016 respectively, according to Monday’s Bernama report quoting Treasury secretary-general Mohd Irwan Serigar Abdullah.

“After corporate tax (reduction), BR1M, refund of sales tax under GST, the next effect of the GST would be RM3.8 billion and RM9 billion to the government in 2015 and 2016 respectively,” said Mohd Irwan.

For KPMG executive director of transfer pricing Bob Kee, the key takeaway from the budget announcement was a clearer picture of federal tax policy from the authorities:

“For practitioners like us, definitely it was a budget we were hoping for. The introduction of GST has been very clear, there is a clear timeline and the rate is known, at 6%. The announcement gives some stability. What is important from now to the Apr 1, 2015 implementation is for the authorities to intensify their awareness campaigns.”

GST education critically needed

Bob Kee

Bob Kee

“For companies, the immediate challenge would be the integration of GST into their operations. With a buffer of 17 months, companies must now assess the impact of GST on their operations and pricing strategies,” Kee explained.

“Although the mechanics of GST are relatively straightforward (that is output tax less input tax), the challenge is in the details as companies must also consider the capability of their IT systems to cope with the demands of GST and the need to educate employees and customers.

“The board of directors must also take care to ensure that pricing strategies are accurately modelled as a wrong decision could impact on the company’s performance,” he added.

Several initiatives to improve GST awareness were listed in the 2013/2014 Ministry of Finance Economic Report last week. They include Royal Malaysian Customs organised nationwide seminars, roadshows and publicity campaigns.

Government help to counter impact of inflation

Economists agree the introduction of GST will result in a one-off inflation event that should taper down to normal levels before the end of 2015.

food-inflation-gst-genericIn Budget 2014, the government promised help to counter the impact of inflation on the people.

“Upon the implementation of GST, the government is committed to providing various forms of assistance to the rakyat during the GST transition period,” said Najib during Friday’s speech.

Chief among the measures include an across the board reduction in individual income taxes of between 1% and 3%.

“Everyone got a share of the tax savings,” said KPMG’s Tam commenting on the individual income tax break to take effect from 2015, corporate tax reduction of 1% and cash assistance schemes.

Despite this, Tam believed revenue from direct tax would continue to rise as the authorities step up their monitoring and enforcement efforts.

In tomorrow’s part three, KiniBiz will turn to other tax reform measures introduced in Budget 2014 aside from GST.

For a further read on the GST, click here for a link to a KiniBiz pre-budget series of articles on GST.

Yesterday: Budget 2014 – What’s out more surprising than what’s in?

Tomorrow: Tax breaks to soothe the sting of GST